Winona Ryder as Melissa Warburton – Then
Any Friends episode with a celebrity cameo appearance was always fun. Winona played Melissa, Rachel’s former sorority sister from college. Apparently, the two ended up making out after drinking too much at a party back in the day. While Rachel saw it as a wild college experience, Melissa fell in love with her but never said a word.
When the two bump into each other in Central Perk, they decide to catch up for dinner, and Phoebe tags along because she doesn’t believe the kiss ever happened. After Melissa denies it as well, Rachel kisses her again just to prove it did. This leads to Melissa declaring her love for Rach, but she breaks her heart by telling her it was just a drunken kiss. Aww!