11. Double Dare’s Dirty Secret
Everyone wanted to be on Double Dare to show off our pop culture smarts we earned through sitting in front of the TV for hours. We also craved the challenge of the wacky obstacle courses and the threat of being covered in gallons of slime. And don’t forget about the pie!
Getting pied in the face by Marc Summers was something to brag about, but the host accidentally hit one contestant too hard with the cream, landing Nickelodeon in a lawsuit. The woman claimed that she was struck so hard she couldn’t do the deed with her husband anymore, and she was given $25,000 in an out-of-court settlement. Summers continues to pie people.