Not The Right Response
When you’re in the first stages of a relationship, you do everything you can to show them you like them, which includes making their birthday extra special. Any old cake wasn’t going to do for u/grafasaurus’ girlfriend. She wanted to show the Redditor she meant business, so picked up a Carvel ice cream cake.
The brand is famous in the US for its special layer of chocolate crunchies that add a fun texture to their cakes. When your girlfriend gives you cake, you say “thank you” and eat up, or at least spare her feelings by fibbing that you’re full from lunch instead of blurting out that you “aren’t really a fan” of her gift.