Step into the spotlight of Hollywood’s grandest affair: the Academy Awards. Each year, the elite Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences bestows coveted Oscars upon standout films and their visionary creators. While these winners ideally evoke admiration, some miss the mark. Perhaps they fail to resonate with the cultural pulse or are dismissed as elitist, catering more to industry insiders than the everyday moviegoer. Despite filmmakers’ best efforts, certain Oscar victors falter under scrutiny. Yet, amidst the glitz and glamour, the Oscars remain a beacon, igniting spirited discussions about the ever-evolving tapestry of cinema.
#34: My Fair Lady, 37th Academy Awards, 1965
Categories: Winner of 8 Academy Awards, including Best Picture and Best Director
Best Actor nominees who lost at the 37th Academy Awards:
- Richard Burton, Becket
- Peter O’Toole, Becket
- Anthony Quinn, Zorba the Greek
- Peter Sellers, Dr. Strangelove or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb
While Rex Harrison undoubtedly possessed talent, his portrayal in My Fair Lady fell short of deserving the Oscar. In the same year, Peter Sellers wowed audiences with his multifaceted roles in Dr. Strangelove, setting a standard of excellence. Moreover, the performances in Becket eclipsed Harrison’s achievement.
Today, Harrison’s character, Henry Higgins, remains a footnote in cinematic history. His win is marred by the patronizing nature of Higgins’ attempts to mold a working-class woman into society’s standards. It’s perplexing how easily lightweight productions like My Fair Lady garner praise, only to fade into obscurity shortly after.